Operation Everest II: Comparison of four instruments for measuring blood O2 saturation

V. A. Forte, M. K. Malconian, R. L. Burse, P. B. Rock, P. M. Young, L. A. Trad, B. A. Ruscio, J. R. Sutton, C. S. Houston, A. Cymerman

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

11 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

The bias and precision of four different methods for determining O2 saturation (SO2) were evaluated during a study of hypobaric hypoxia conducted with seven male subjects exposed progressively over a 40-day period to simulated altitudes from sea level (760 Torr) to 8,840 m (240 Torr). SO2 of arterial and mixed venous blood samples were measured with the Instrumentation Laboratory 282 CO-oximeter (CO-OX), the Radiometer ABL-300 (ABL), and the Lex-O2-Con-K (LEX). Noninvasive measurements of arterial SO2 were made with a Hewlett-Packard 47201A ear oximeter (EAR-OX). The CO-OX method was used as a secondary standard for comparison with the other methods because it has been validated against the classical Van Slyke method over a wide physiological range (Maas et al., Clin. Chim. Acta 29: 303-309, 1970). The LEX results most closely approximated but consistently underestimated those of the CO-OX: LEX = 0.93 CO-OX -0.86, standard error of the estimate (SEE) = 5.17, r = 0.98, n = 670. The ABL method appeared to combine two linear trends: for SO2 > 75%, ABL = 0.84 CO-OX +14.4, SEE = 1.77, r = 0.97, n = 369; < 75%, ABL = 0.98 CO-OX +5.9, SEE = 4.44, r = 0.97, n = 486. The EAR-OX results were found to approximate those of the CO-OX at SO2 values only > 65%: EAR-OX = > 1.07 CO-OX -6.12, SEE = 7.71, r = 0.98, n = 326. In a separate experiment, the CO-OX, LEX, and ABL methods were used to determine the SO2 of human blood previously tonometered with eight gases of known O2 concentrations to produce saturations from 13.3 to 99.7%. This test confirmed the CO-OX as being the most accurate and precise of the three methods. Of the other two, the ABL was the most precise. The LEX although of lesser precision had the better accuracy, approximating that of the CO-OX.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)2135-2140
Number of pages6
JournalJournal of Applied Physiology
Volume67
Issue number5
StatePublished - 1 Dec 1989

Fingerprint

Carbon Monoxide
Ear
Oceans and Seas
Gases

Keywords

  • Altitude
  • hypobaric hypoxia
  • mixed venous saturation
  • tonometry

Cite this

Forte, V. A., Malconian, M. K., Burse, R. L., Rock, P. B., Young, P. M., Trad, L. A., ... Cymerman, A. (1989). Operation Everest II: Comparison of four instruments for measuring blood O2 saturation. Journal of Applied Physiology, 67(5), 2135-2140.
Forte, V. A. ; Malconian, M. K. ; Burse, R. L. ; Rock, P. B. ; Young, P. M. ; Trad, L. A. ; Ruscio, B. A. ; Sutton, J. R. ; Houston, C. S. ; Cymerman, A. / Operation Everest II : Comparison of four instruments for measuring blood O2 saturation. In: Journal of Applied Physiology. 1989 ; Vol. 67, No. 5. pp. 2135-2140.
@article{9adf683c38f94e69ab3e997b01af1731,
title = "Operation Everest II: Comparison of four instruments for measuring blood O2 saturation",
abstract = "The bias and precision of four different methods for determining O2 saturation (SO2) were evaluated during a study of hypobaric hypoxia conducted with seven male subjects exposed progressively over a 40-day period to simulated altitudes from sea level (760 Torr) to 8,840 m (240 Torr). SO2 of arterial and mixed venous blood samples were measured with the Instrumentation Laboratory 282 CO-oximeter (CO-OX), the Radiometer ABL-300 (ABL), and the Lex-O2-Con-K (LEX). Noninvasive measurements of arterial SO2 were made with a Hewlett-Packard 47201A ear oximeter (EAR-OX). The CO-OX method was used as a secondary standard for comparison with the other methods because it has been validated against the classical Van Slyke method over a wide physiological range (Maas et al., Clin. Chim. Acta 29: 303-309, 1970). The LEX results most closely approximated but consistently underestimated those of the CO-OX: LEX = 0.93 CO-OX -0.86, standard error of the estimate (SEE) = 5.17, r = 0.98, n = 670. The ABL method appeared to combine two linear trends: for SO2 > 75{\%}, ABL = 0.84 CO-OX +14.4, SEE = 1.77, r = 0.97, n = 369; < 75{\%}, ABL = 0.98 CO-OX +5.9, SEE = 4.44, r = 0.97, n = 486. The EAR-OX results were found to approximate those of the CO-OX at SO2 values only > 65{\%}: EAR-OX = > 1.07 CO-OX -6.12, SEE = 7.71, r = 0.98, n = 326. In a separate experiment, the CO-OX, LEX, and ABL methods were used to determine the SO2 of human blood previously tonometered with eight gases of known O2 concentrations to produce saturations from 13.3 to 99.7{\%}. This test confirmed the CO-OX as being the most accurate and precise of the three methods. Of the other two, the ABL was the most precise. The LEX although of lesser precision had the better accuracy, approximating that of the CO-OX.",
keywords = "Altitude, hypobaric hypoxia, mixed venous saturation, tonometry",
author = "Forte, {V. A.} and Malconian, {M. K.} and Burse, {R. L.} and Rock, {P. B.} and Young, {P. M.} and Trad, {L. A.} and Ruscio, {B. A.} and Sutton, {J. R.} and Houston, {C. S.} and A. Cymerman",
year = "1989",
month = "12",
day = "1",
language = "English",
volume = "67",
pages = "2135--2140",
journal = "Journal of Applied Physiology",
issn = "8750-7587",
publisher = "American Physiological Society",
number = "5",

}

Forte, VA, Malconian, MK, Burse, RL, Rock, PB, Young, PM, Trad, LA, Ruscio, BA, Sutton, JR, Houston, CS & Cymerman, A 1989, 'Operation Everest II: Comparison of four instruments for measuring blood O2 saturation', Journal of Applied Physiology, vol. 67, no. 5, pp. 2135-2140.

Operation Everest II : Comparison of four instruments for measuring blood O2 saturation. / Forte, V. A.; Malconian, M. K.; Burse, R. L.; Rock, P. B.; Young, P. M.; Trad, L. A.; Ruscio, B. A.; Sutton, J. R.; Houston, C. S.; Cymerman, A.

In: Journal of Applied Physiology, Vol. 67, No. 5, 01.12.1989, p. 2135-2140.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Operation Everest II

T2 - Comparison of four instruments for measuring blood O2 saturation

AU - Forte, V. A.

AU - Malconian, M. K.

AU - Burse, R. L.

AU - Rock, P. B.

AU - Young, P. M.

AU - Trad, L. A.

AU - Ruscio, B. A.

AU - Sutton, J. R.

AU - Houston, C. S.

AU - Cymerman, A.

PY - 1989/12/1

Y1 - 1989/12/1

N2 - The bias and precision of four different methods for determining O2 saturation (SO2) were evaluated during a study of hypobaric hypoxia conducted with seven male subjects exposed progressively over a 40-day period to simulated altitudes from sea level (760 Torr) to 8,840 m (240 Torr). SO2 of arterial and mixed venous blood samples were measured with the Instrumentation Laboratory 282 CO-oximeter (CO-OX), the Radiometer ABL-300 (ABL), and the Lex-O2-Con-K (LEX). Noninvasive measurements of arterial SO2 were made with a Hewlett-Packard 47201A ear oximeter (EAR-OX). The CO-OX method was used as a secondary standard for comparison with the other methods because it has been validated against the classical Van Slyke method over a wide physiological range (Maas et al., Clin. Chim. Acta 29: 303-309, 1970). The LEX results most closely approximated but consistently underestimated those of the CO-OX: LEX = 0.93 CO-OX -0.86, standard error of the estimate (SEE) = 5.17, r = 0.98, n = 670. The ABL method appeared to combine two linear trends: for SO2 > 75%, ABL = 0.84 CO-OX +14.4, SEE = 1.77, r = 0.97, n = 369; < 75%, ABL = 0.98 CO-OX +5.9, SEE = 4.44, r = 0.97, n = 486. The EAR-OX results were found to approximate those of the CO-OX at SO2 values only > 65%: EAR-OX = > 1.07 CO-OX -6.12, SEE = 7.71, r = 0.98, n = 326. In a separate experiment, the CO-OX, LEX, and ABL methods were used to determine the SO2 of human blood previously tonometered with eight gases of known O2 concentrations to produce saturations from 13.3 to 99.7%. This test confirmed the CO-OX as being the most accurate and precise of the three methods. Of the other two, the ABL was the most precise. The LEX although of lesser precision had the better accuracy, approximating that of the CO-OX.

AB - The bias and precision of four different methods for determining O2 saturation (SO2) were evaluated during a study of hypobaric hypoxia conducted with seven male subjects exposed progressively over a 40-day period to simulated altitudes from sea level (760 Torr) to 8,840 m (240 Torr). SO2 of arterial and mixed venous blood samples were measured with the Instrumentation Laboratory 282 CO-oximeter (CO-OX), the Radiometer ABL-300 (ABL), and the Lex-O2-Con-K (LEX). Noninvasive measurements of arterial SO2 were made with a Hewlett-Packard 47201A ear oximeter (EAR-OX). The CO-OX method was used as a secondary standard for comparison with the other methods because it has been validated against the classical Van Slyke method over a wide physiological range (Maas et al., Clin. Chim. Acta 29: 303-309, 1970). The LEX results most closely approximated but consistently underestimated those of the CO-OX: LEX = 0.93 CO-OX -0.86, standard error of the estimate (SEE) = 5.17, r = 0.98, n = 670. The ABL method appeared to combine two linear trends: for SO2 > 75%, ABL = 0.84 CO-OX +14.4, SEE = 1.77, r = 0.97, n = 369; < 75%, ABL = 0.98 CO-OX +5.9, SEE = 4.44, r = 0.97, n = 486. The EAR-OX results were found to approximate those of the CO-OX at SO2 values only > 65%: EAR-OX = > 1.07 CO-OX -6.12, SEE = 7.71, r = 0.98, n = 326. In a separate experiment, the CO-OX, LEX, and ABL methods were used to determine the SO2 of human blood previously tonometered with eight gases of known O2 concentrations to produce saturations from 13.3 to 99.7%. This test confirmed the CO-OX as being the most accurate and precise of the three methods. Of the other two, the ABL was the most precise. The LEX although of lesser precision had the better accuracy, approximating that of the CO-OX.

KW - Altitude

KW - hypobaric hypoxia

KW - mixed venous saturation

KW - tonometry

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=0024804737&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

C2 - 2600041

AN - SCOPUS:0024804737

VL - 67

SP - 2135

EP - 2140

JO - Journal of Applied Physiology

JF - Journal of Applied Physiology

SN - 8750-7587

IS - 5

ER -

Forte VA, Malconian MK, Burse RL, Rock PB, Young PM, Trad LA et al. Operation Everest II: Comparison of four instruments for measuring blood O2 saturation. Journal of Applied Physiology. 1989 Dec 1;67(5):2135-2140.